How to Buy Pasta Like an Italian

I love pasta so much that I eat it four or five times a week. And no, that’s not an exaggeration. When you buy pasta as often as I do, you start to notice the difference very quickly. 

In Italy, pasta isn’t just food. It’s culture. It’s history. It’s something you grow up with, something that’s part of everyday life. That’s exactly why I care so much about choosing the right one. 

I know some people think pasta is pasta. Grab the cheapest packet, job done. I get it, we all want to save money where we can. But here’s the truth, not all pasta is the same, and the difference really shows once it hits the plate. 

In this guide, I’m going to show you how to buy pasta properly, what actually matters, what doesn’t, and why spending just a little more can completely change your pasta experience.

Watch: How to Buy Pasta Like an Italian (Stop Making This Mistake)

Two Ways Pasta Is Extruded 

There are two main ways dry pasta is extruded. 

One uses plastic or teflon extruders. This gives pasta a very smooth finish and usually makes it cheaper. Sometimes it’s even too perfect, and for pasta, perfect isn’t what we want. 

The other method uses bronze extruders. This gives pasta a more rustic look and a rougher surface. That rough texture is everything. Smooth pasta made with teflon doesn’t absorb sauce very well, the sauce simply slips off. Bronze-cut pasta, on the other hand, holds sauce beautifully. 

This is extremely important when choosing pasta and deciding which pasta to buy. A good pasta brand will usually say on the packaging whether it’s bronze cut, and high-quality brands often also tell you how long the pasta has been dried for. 

Drying, Colour, and Why It Tells the Truth 

When it comes to pasta, drying matters more than most people realise. 

Good pasta is dried slowly at low temperatures, usually between 30 and 40°C, for anywhere from 10 to 30 hours. I once visited a very proud pasta factory in Abruzzo where they dry pasta for up to 48 hours. 

Yes, you pay a little more for this kind of pasta, but what you get in return is worth it. The pasta holds its shape, absorbs sauce extremely well, and gives you a much better texture on the plate. Semolina quality is important, but the drying temperature and time are even more critical. 

So what should you look for when you buy pasta? Colour. Good pasta is very light in colour, almost white or a very pale yellow. If the pasta is dark yellow or almost orange, that’s a bad sign. It usually means it was dried at high temperatures for a short time. 

Cheaper pasta is often darker and can have stains or black spots. The shape may also be inconsistent. A respected pasta brand will go through strict quality control and wouldn’t let pasta like that reach the shelf. 

Price Comparison: How to Buy Pasta Without Overpaying 

Of course, all pasta can be eaten. Even the cheapest one will feed your family. But cheap pasta is usually low in protein, low in fibre, doesn’t hold its shape well, and doesn’t absorb sauce properly. 

A $2.50 pasta might be straight in shape, which is good, but if it’s dark in colour and has black spots, that tells me it likely didn’t pass proper quality control. 

Move up slightly, and you’ll find a good commercial pasta around the $3.50 to $4 mark. These are often lighter in colour, bronze cut, properly dried, and free from spots. This is the pasta I use most days. It’s only about 50 cents more than cheaper options, but the quality difference is huge. 

Then you have premium pasta at around $6 or $7. Very pale, beautifully rough, and often dried for over 40 hours. You can immediately see the difference when you put it side by side with cheaper pasta. It’s top quality, but not something everyone wants to buy every day, and that’s fair. 

Cooking Time Says a Lot 

Another detail many people overlook when they buy pasta is cooking time.

Better pasta often says it’s ready al dente in around 9 or 10 minutes. That wording matters. Al dente means “to the tooth”, the pasta still has structure. 

Cheaper pasta might say 13 or 14 minutes but doesn’t mention al dente. Follow that timing, and it often turns too soft or mushy. If a packet doesn’t talk about al dente, I’m already cautious. 

Conclusion: Spend Smart, Not Blindly 

All pasta can be eaten, that’s not the question. Yes, you can feed your family with a one-dollar packet of pasta, but you should know what you’re getting. Lower quality, fewer nutrients, and a worse result on the plate. 

If you don’t eat pasta often, spend the extra dollar and enjoy it properly. Artisan pasta at $6 or $7 might not be for everyone, but to me, if six dollars feeds my whole family, that’s good value. A coffee costs the same and only pleases one person. 

If I need to compromise, I buy a good quality commercial pasta around the $4 mark. That’s the sweet spot. It gives you a much better pasta experience and lets the sauce do its job. 

Now that I’ve shared how I choose pasta and how I buy pasta at the supermarket, let me know in the comments, what’s your favourite pasta brand, and why do you like it so much?

Next time you’re at the supermarket, choose wisely. 
Buy the right pasta. 

Subscribe to my Youtube Channel: www.youtube.com/vincenzosplate

Interested in Italy?

Join my private exclusive “Italy Unexplored Tour” and experience the real Italy, like you have never seen before!

This tour is exclusive to only 10 passionate foodies and is very unique.

Get the details