Ranking Italian Cheeses (From Worst to Best)

Italian cheeses are some of the most loved in the world. From creamy burrata to aged Parmigiano Reggiano, they are a huge part of Italian food culture.

But here is the truth. Not everything sold as “Italian cheese” deserves a place on your kitchen.

Some cheeses are rich, balanced, and full of character while others are over-processed, dry, or completely lacking flavour. The difference is not just about price. It comes down to how the cheese is made, how it is aged, and how fresh it is.

I grew up eating real Italian cheese, the kind made by artisans who respect tradition. And honestly, once you taste that, it becomes very hard to go back.

So today, I am ranking a mix of traditional Italian cheeses and common supermarket cheese products, grouped into tiers from worst to best. We will be looking at flavour, texture, and how they are actually meant to be enjoyed.

Watch: Ranking Italian Cheeses from Gross to GOD TIER

Ranking Italian Cheeses (From Worst to Best) 

F Tier – Cheese Crimes 

Pre-Grated Cheese Mix 

Let’s be honest. Most pre-grated cheese mixes are not real cheese in the way you hope. Check the ingredients and you will often find anti-caking agents hiding in there. As a result, this affects the flavour, the texture, and the way it melts. Instead of creamy and delicious, you get something dry, dusty, and a little bit sad. 

For me, this is the absolute bottom tier.  Buy a wedge. Grate it fresh. Your pasta deserves better. 

C Tier – Useful but Limited

Grana Padano

Often compared to Parmigiano Reggiano, and yes, they are similar. Grana Padano is more affordable and works very well in cooking. It melts nicely into sauces and is great for pasta dishes.

But if you want to eat cheese on its own, I would still choose Parmigiano or Pecorino.

B Tier – Good Everyday Choices

Provolone

Sharp, slightly spicy, and perfect for sandwiches, this is a very versatile cheese that melts well and adds character to simple dishes. It is not as complex as aged cheeses, but it does its job very well.

A very solid everyday cheese.

Ricotta

Soft, delicate, and slightly sweet. It works beautifully in cannoli, pasta fillings, and baked dishes. But on its own, it can feel a bit plain. Most of the time, it needs something extra like honey, fruit, or herbs to enjoy this cheese.

A good cheese, but not the most exciting on its own.

A Tier – Excellent Cheeses

Gorgonzola

This is one of those cheeses you either love or run away from.

It has a strong aroma, looks suspicious but with creamy texture, and spicy flavour. It can be intense, but that is part of its charm.

Asiago

Fresh Asiago is mild and slightly sweet. However, aged Asiago becomes firmer and more intense flavor. It works beautifully on a cheese board, in cooking, or just eaten on its own.

Simple, balanced, and always a good choice.

Taleggio

Yes, it smells strong. In fact, it is one of the smelliest cheeses in Italy. But once you taste it, it is surprisingly mil and buttery.

It melts beautifully and is perfect in dishes like polenta. That said, this is a classic case of do not judge a cheese by its smell alone.

Fontina

This is one of the best melting cheeses in Italy. Rich, smooth, and perfect fondue or anything that needs a cheesy coating. As a result, it creates that beautiful creamy texture without overpowering the dish.

Very underrated.

S Tier – True Italian Legends

Fior di Latte Mozzarella

Fresh, delicate, and incredibly versatile.

You can use it on pizza, in salads, in panini, or simply eat it on its own. When it is fresh, it is impossible not to love.

Mozzarella di Bufala

A completely different experience. Creamy, rich, and full of flavour. A real milk explosion. However, it must be eaten fresh. Do not cook it, as it releases too much water.

Enjoy it as it is, with good olive oil and maybe a little salt.

Burrata

When it is made properly, this is one of the best cheeses you will ever taste. Creamy on the inside, delicate on the outside, and full of flavour.

But here is the problem. Outside of Italy, it is not always easy to find good burrata. If you find high-quality artisan burrata, it is absolutely S tier.

Mascarpone 

Rich, smooth, and indulgent. With 50% this is basically cheese dressed like dessert. 

Yes, it is famous for tiramisu, but it can also be used in savoury dishes. It adds a creamy texture that is hard to beat. 

Parmigiano Reggiano 

The king. If it is not aged at least 24 months, do not even talk to me.  At 30 months or more, it becomes something special. Nutty, complex, and full of depth. 

This is not just cheese. This is a life choice. 

Pecorino Romano 

My everyday cheese. Salty, sharp, and packed with flavour. You cannot make a proper carbonara without it. 

For this reason, this is the cheese I reach for all the time. Strong, bold, and reliable. 

Final Thoughts on Italian Cheeses

Life is too short for bad cheese.

If you take one thing from this, let it be this. Choose quality whenever you can. Even small changes, like grating your cheese fresh or choosing a better product, can completely transform your cooking.

Italian food is simple. That is why every ingredient matters.

And if I missed one of your favourite Italian cheeses, let me know in the comments. I would love to hear your thoughts.

Subscribe to my Youtube Channel: www.youtube.com/vincenzosplate